The current HowDoI wiki states Please do not add any new "How Do I" pages
. Instead write a tutorial for the developer.gnome.org website i.
I see problems with the new site:
(1) No clear content boundaries given.
HowDoI gave a clear spectrum of what it should contain.
The new page does not. It simply says “tutorial”.
Expected Problems:
Some tutorials will be for ultimate beginners, some for advanced users. Rating and improvement of tutorials will become difficult.
Suggestion:
Create a site stating what granularity you expect the tutorials to be.
(2) Creation / Edit hurdle very high
HowDoIs were easy to create: Open non-existing site, click “create”, write your stuff; Edit on occasions.
The new page requires you to install software locally and to build your tutorial. Further, it does not give
Expected Problems:
Not many people will be eager to write a tutorial here. It’s much easier then to write it in a blog, in one’s own wiki or in some document (google docs / offline). The outcome is, that (again) tutorials and information will be spread on the internet and hard to find. This might lead to a value loss of GTK, as dev cost is going up with missing information.
Suggestion:
Make the system easier to approach. Even if the backend is what it is, build a wiki-style interface around it, which makes things easy to correct.
(3) Searchability / Viewability
Judging from the root page of the new site, tutorials apparently ought to be read and searched for on Gitlab.
Expected Problems:
The content won’t be searchable by search engines rendering them very unuseful for newcomers who don’t already know where to look for.
Suggestion:
Create usual html pages on gnome.org containing the content. And always put a link to the source inside the document, so users who want to edit can edit.