GdkPixbuf 2.42 build-time options change

Platform
#1

Hi all;

GdkPixbuf 2.42.0 introduced new build-time options to increase consistency with the rest of the GNOME core platform:

  • the docs option has been deprecated; it’s now recommended to use the gtk_doc option to build the API reference for GdkPixbuf, and the man option to build the manual pages for the various tools
  • the gir option has been renamed to introspection, and it uses a “feature” type instead of a boolean one

In both cases, the change was made to match what other GNOME libraries already do.

#2

Out of curiosity: would it be possible to have all options consistent by using the dash to separate words? So it should read gtk-doc instead of gtk_doc. Right now, for example, all other options in https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gtk/-/blob/master/meson_options.txt use the dash.

just asking…
Thanks in advance!

#3

You will need to convince every project to follow the same patterns. The existing best practices are encoded in the wiki, and gtk_doc is preferred.

1 Like
#4

In particular, from the guidelines that Emmanuele just linked to:

  • Use a consistent separator character for multi-word options, preferably the underscore _, like cert_file or cups_print_backend

So to comply with these guidelines, GTK should rename all its build options to use underscores, instead. It’s going to be a lot easier to do that before GTK 4 is released, rather than later…

1 Like
#5

The counter here is that it is not “gtk doc” for underscore to be used for multi-word options. It actually is quite literally gtk-doc, hence a hyphen is appropriate, as it’s not a multi-word that’s being put together here.
It’s not gtk docs, it’s gtk-doc format documentation.

However I’ve stopped worrying about this and accept I get to sometimes (more often) write $(meson_use gtk-doc gtk_doc) instead of $(meson_use gtk-doc) in my downstream packages.

#6

This topic was automatically closed 14 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.