Board concerns on recent mastodon thread

I’m writing as GNOME Foundation President, on behalf of the Foundation in regard to a thread on mastodon referenced at निर्भीक चौहान: "In case anyone is wondering why it's so tiring to…" - Hachyderm.io .

We’ve seen people in this thread attack each other personally and assume the worst of one another, and we’ve seen that some community members have decided to leave the project as a result. That is a huge loss, and it is not the kind of community we want to be.

GNOME brings together people from many backgrounds, places and opinions. Sometimes we find ourselves in disagreement, and that is OK - as a diverse project, we are not going to always have the same perspectives. What is not OK is personal attacks, attributing motives to others, and escalating exchanges. These behaviors make it harder for everyone to participate.

Everyone should be able to take part in GNOME without fear of discrimination or hostility. Community members absolutely should raise concerns if they feel unsafe. However, a legitimate need for safety does not justify treating other people as inherently unsafe, hostile, or undeserving of dignity or empathy. Strong feelings, difficult experiences, and deeply held convictions are welcome and understood in GNOME; personal attacks, shaming, dehumanizing language, and intimidation that drive others out are not.

Setting and enforcing these standards is the responsibility of the Foundation and the Code of Conduct Committee. If you are reading this thread, we want you to know that we are paying attention. The Code of Conduct Committee will be reviewing reports about this thread, and the Board is actively considering steps to improve how we handle community conflict.

If you’ve been affected by this discussion, you can contact the Code of Conduct Committee (https://conduct.gnome.org/), or schedule a call with me or any other director you feel comfortable with. We want to hear from you.

Update: please see Follow-up to post on Board concerns

14 Likes

Hi sri

I am disappointed that this is your (and the board’s) interpretation of what happened. It equates and gives equal weight to what established, privileged, members of our community do, to what our younger and more minoritized members did in response.

Nirbheek screenshots come from an opinion piece covering a popular story about a queer bar in the US that descended into infighting over various accommodations they made for their patrons. The section presented by Nirbheek as entirely sincere and serious, is in fact just a personal anecdote by the columnist to illustrate a similar, farcical, experience to the one of the bar owners in the original story. It would not be unfair to call this clipping a misrepresentation of the author’s humorous intention.

There is also a more important nuance in the choice of this article. Nirbheek commentary is, and has been, targeting contributors who have openly criticized any acceptance of LLM generated content in GNOME. Most of these folk are openly queer themselves, or a minority in some other fashion. Clipping a quote about a caricature story about “inclusion gone mad”, is not an innocent mistake. At best it is a clueless action that would warrant ignoring any “over reaction” to it.

The ensuing discussion in the thread caught some by surprise because they are unfamiliar with the above nuances of “online discourse”, or are not required to be hyper vigilant for their own safety. Adrien correctly explains in the thread:

Just so you know, for many multi-minorized persons, holding lists is a matter of literal life and death. Not having to hold lists is a privilege, and one that I have too.
Hachyderm.io

I take issue with the characterization of the thread as “people (…) attack each other personally and assume the worst of one another”. I can understand that the defensiveness of the queer folk in the thread can be perceived as an “attack”, but as explained by Alice:

Unlike you, I have to live in a very precarious situation (…) because I would most likely be arrested if I tried to come back, because of a combination of my identity (‘“lgbt movement” declared extremist’) and being vocal about politics (…) I can’t take any chances and have to be suspicious. Especially when there already were people in gnome who turned out to be the russian variety of bad apples
Alice :neocat_flag_transbian: (@alice) | Nyaa~ Place

I will also protest the implied innocence of the “community members (that) have decided to leave the project as a result”. They were in fact throwing seniority around, as if it made them more important than the current project contributors, while also demonstrating lack of empathy for them:

You’re saying as if Nirbheek himself is some sort of outsider. He’s been part of the community for much longer than many of these problematic people.
Mastodon

Telling a long-term GNOME contributor that they are misrepresenting the GNOME community, it very much sounds like that to anyone who is not familiar with his history.
Hachyderm.io

Not to mention, of course, that the history of GNOME is actually closer to the what is being defended by the queer folk accused of being irascible attackers by our respectable contributors.

It is not serious analysis, or sincere care for community, to say that queer folk being hyper vigilant because online danger easily turns into IRL danger for them, is the same as a few privileged engineers having their feelings hurt because they got yelled on Mastodon. When minoritized people clown on privileged people, the only ones in IRL danger are the minoritized people.

34 Likes

This is quite the stress inducing take on this situation… I’m just a user, but this gives me a huge ick about using Gnome in the future.

I for one, feel strongly that I would not feel comfortable for adverse action take against the minority in this situation, else the minority protections in the code of conduct are merely for show. I truly love Gnome as a project, the design, the contributors, but this situation’s outcome will be the final straw for me as a user for considering Gnome on future installs, as I would not feel safe in the community anymore.

I personally believe this interpretation of the situation is quite dismissive of the community and genuine concerns brought forth.

For whatever these thoughts are worth, simply sharing my view as a longtime user of Gnome.

19 Likes

Honestly, this is an unsafe view of people in survival mode because it is based on a privileged perspective. Most of us (myself included) are fortunate enough to have an income, plenty of time, and sometimes medication, as well as access to therapy and counselling, to reflect on our actions and feelings.

This is not the case for people who don’t have these things, and it’s significantly worse for victims who are witnessing everything they love(d) falling apart, including their close(st) friends, and have no choice but to interrogate them with the hope that there’s a glimmer of hope for their friendship.

Considering the above, it’s completely unfair to act like it’s our place, as privileged individuals, to say it’s not justified. The most we can say is it’s humiliating and uncomfortable for the person being interrogated, but calling it unjustified is, ironically, unjustified.

19 Likes

Tbh, like I indicated on the thread, the post was throwaway rage bait, and coating the situation with platitudes about respecting each other isn’t going to change that. I know your intentions are good, but I have zero patience for cry bullies in any form, and my decision to defend my distressed co-contributors is something I stand behind. If people are truly are this shaken up by someone publicly posting extremely inflammatory and insulting language unprovoked and getting a fraction of a taste of their own medicine in return, then idk what to say, other than I’ve severely overestimated the integrity of this community.

21 Likes

I think this is the end of my GNOME story. I think I’m gonna resign my Foundation membership and move to other things in life. If the official Board statement ignores safety of trans people (MY safety), then I am going to protect myself, and stop sacrificing my free time for people who gladly defended bigoted assholes.

CoCC and Board clearly do not care about safety of queers. This has been proven by past actions, where CoCC willingly ignored the shitstorm that happened in Foundation members Matrix chat, where Nirbheek clearly violated (multiple times) CoC, and I quoted that in the linked Mastodon thread. But apparently, me (and others) calling out people who objectively make the community more unsafe for queers was deemed unacceptable by the Board and CoCC.

Enough is enough. That’s enough for me.

If calling out bigots is unacceptable in GNOME in 2026 because GNOME is “”“diverse”“” community, then Board and CoCC clearly have a… curious and rather interesting interpretation of the word. I do not belong in the “diverse marketplace of ideas” where bigots are protected.

Bye.

31 Likes

I’ll give the same post as I put on the internal channel. I’m not sure if that’s how I interpret this, but to me this feels like a slap on the wrist on people calling out a very toxic post that is bordering on the slanderous.

I’ll be completely honest, and will say that I don’t know what the right course of action here is either. I am very well aware that I don’t really belong to any marginalized group, and dismissing real safety concerns from my side does not feel right. Neither do I want to feel attacked on behalf of others. However, what I will say is that I have full understanding for the people that reacted quite sharply to this, especially when they are personally affected by this rhetoric. To me this very strongly feels like giving a scolding to the person that is lashes out at a bully, and that never really helps to repair communities.

Again, I am not part of the CoCC, and neither am I affected by this directly. But I sure hope for a bit more nuance than that we should be nicer to attacks on marginalized people within the community. That doesn’t mean that everyone should have the same, or even similar opinions as me. But there are lines to be drawn when it comes to fully respecting our fellow contributors as equals.
And respecting our fellow contributors as equals also refers to moves like giving people some pretense of immunity due to seniority. That is really a form of gatekeeping that actively drives away newcomers.

16 Likes

To be honest, I’m also heavily considering moving on to new things. Although I did not start developing Bazaar with the intention of it entering GNOME Circle or potentially Core, this official post as written on behalf of the foundation has made every ounce of desire to participate in this project completely leave my body.

For years before Bazaar, it was my dream to participate directly in GNOME and collaborate with the many insanely talented developers and designers that make up the project. I’ve spent countless hours learning the ins and outs of GTK and C programming by my own accord because I found fascinating the technical design of the underlying technology and saw GNOME as a beacon of hope in a cruel world that didn’t accept me for who I was.

Collaborating with other GNOME designers and developers over the past year and a half has been probably among the most fulfilling things I’ve ever had the pleasure to experience. This project has some of the smartest, funniest, most deeply empathetic people I have ever met. But fostering an environment for these people to thrive is clearly not a goal by the ones running the show as indicated by the decision of the COCC to endorse this post.

19 Likes

If this message is banned, then ban me too. I stand in solidarity with the community.

14 Likes

As someone who’s just dipping their toes into starting contributing to the project (beyond one or two sporadic contributions and issues opened over these years) after almost a decade as a mere user and almost a couple of years as a donor, that’s more than just a terrible response from the board. Hopefully, my opinion won’t be treated as lesser due to not being a senior contributor, nor will it be treated as a “drive-by whining”.

One can’t simply say they are “a diverse project” and then proceed to stay “neutral” in a conflict where one has a clear statement that “it’s so tiring to participate in a project because [these certain] people want to have morals and discuss ethics”. Specially in a free software project, where the whole “software freedom” thing is inherently an ethical and political philosophy at its core. And specially when their whole point (and comments outside the thread) is coated in a highly “anti-woke” prose.

It’s not surprising why some queer contributors to the project immediately confronted the original poster. What’s surprising to me, baffling even, is seeing the project’s “leadership” discover through this incident that they missed almost a whole year of CoC reports, pretty much not address this in their response to the incident, and try to “stay neutral” by completely ignoring the sociopolitical aspects of the incident and equating the response to the initial attack.

This is not an ultimatum, a “change your behavior immediately or I WILL leave the project, stop donating and never use it again” statement, but, just as other contributors, I stand in solidarity with the folk that decide to stop using, contributing or donating to the project after seeing these simply immature responses from what’s supposed to be the leadership of a project and a pillar of a community of this size.

To be in a position of leadership in a community project you need to understand how to actually respond to conflict, and that means, more than anything, addressing the root causes. As respectfully as this can possibly be, get your sh*t together.

23 Likes

Hi everyone, I’m writing this from the perspective of the silent part of the community that doesn’t post on discourse. I’ve been a long time lurker on the forum and have been amazed by the work done by the GNOME project in matter of code and diversity.

Which is why it saddens me to post as my first message my dissapointment in this situation and handling of it by the GNOME Foundation.
GNOME prides itself to make inclusion and diversity a very important matter through programs like Outreachy and events like GUADEC and others. it is even stated in the project’s mission on the about page.
Which is why I do not understand the reaction. We’ve seen more and more attacks on minorities’ rights lately and i would expect GNOME to be the one that respects them given the previously stated values.

GNOME has a very important place in my heart since it’s the first DE that I used since starting linux and i sticked to it. It also gave me the desire to start contributing to opensource and to immerse myself in the FOSS culture.
I am myself not part of the queer or trans minority, but would consider respecting an individual rights to be a basic thing and REALLY thrive to be better if those basic requirements are not respected. (Fun fact: I used to follow the Frame.work community before the “big tent” phase and would no touch it now with a ten foot pole, even after that whole “apologies” from the CEO)
I also want to add that i saw the post before it being flagged and could not see anything more that someone expressing their opinion after being faced with that kind of responce.

So that’s my opinion as a simple user that occasionaly does translation duties for the french team (sorry for the mistakes in grammar or anything) and I’m just sad how that whole situation is moving forward, especially after the precedents in the CoCC. I hope the Foundation can see themself in the mirror, acknoledge the problem and, as said by many people, get their shit together

15 Likes

To be blunt, I’m really upset with how this has apparently been handled by the foundation and the board, especially when this is the tier of statement that is being made. It’s really unfortunate to see the foundation choose to side with privilege and silencing marginalised community members rather than trying to understand their concerns.

As someone who has always been vaugely around, but never really that involved outside of some adjacent side projects, this is really disappointing and has had me thinking twice about contributing/getting involved in the future. I completely understand why people would be looking to distance themselves from the project due to this.

I really hope that the board and the CoCC take the proper time to reflect on this behaviour, and why it’s alienating people. I know that GNOME is an organisation and community that should be above this, and I’d like to not be proven wrong here.

18 Likes

Greetings to all present.

I shall dispense with the platitudes and expected circumlocution that is expected of respondents and get straight to the point. As a GNOME user and occasional non-code contributor to certain open source projects, I consider the board’s decision to use perceived slights against some idealized veneer of civility in order to chastise and penalize marginalized contributors for speaking out a genuine travesty.

At present, it’s rather apparent that there is a considerable disparity in the treatment of minority contributors and established, privileged members of the GNOME community. Penalizing a contributor for some perceived failure to leave the project on cordial terms while glossing over blatant disregard for the GNOME Code of Conduct by established members is a travesty.

It is not uncommon for minorities to be bludgeoned into compliance for not meeting unfair expectations, and for daring to speak out against problematic behavior, I just find it rather dispiriting that the COCC has opted to prioritize the welfare of privileged GNOME community members over the plight of people in actual danger in this political climate.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

TLDR: The GNOME foundation should really get its affairs in order.

13 Likes

i know not this nirbheek but them citing this article and going “haha so gnome” sounds like an open attempt to stir trouble and conflict in the community

and to be doing so by targeting people who have targets on their back already. Which does make strong reactions unsurprising

i dont think asking people already a lot on edge to not react to provocation, is a kind thing to do.

a community does not thrive when it allows such cheap shots by people like nirbheek

16 Likes

Hi, um I decided to finally make an account for this (I’m in the same boat as Izzy) and honestly I’m just really disappointed. I thought Gnome was supposed to be for enabling and protecting minorities, but I suppose that was too much to hope for. Victim blaming, and especially victim blaming a group of people who’re in survival mode, is genuinely just awful behavior. But I guess that’s what privileged people defending other privileged people is all about. I really do hope you all see all of the comments here and learn to be better than this.

11 Likes

The problem is you are missing essential non-public context that would possibly significantly alter your interpretation of what is going on here. (Or possibly not. Other community members do not agree with me.) Further litigating this situation in public is just going to make us all look bad. Suffice to say the GNOME community currently has a few serious problems that we need to work through, which is not going to happen successfully here in Discourse. And what I’m reading here is wildly distorted from the reality of what is actually going on. I know such a vague reply is very frustrating, but this topic is sensitive and people are hurt.

At least I can assure you that GNOME’s Code of Conduct contains strong protections for marginalized people in the Safety versus Comfort section. Whoever wrote that did a great job. I am confident that the GNOME community truly embraces these values, and that the Code of Conduct Committee stands ready to enforce them if appropriate.

2 Likes

I’m sure a lot of people wouldn’t trust you on this, and trust can only be reestablished by being transparent. Someone who has had access to these information already left the Foundation because they no longer feel comfortable here, which leaves me many doubts to your statement. Could you please publish these ‘essential non-public’ context here?

12 Likes

Agreed on wanting to see the non-public contents.

transparency is vital to community trust, it is easy to say anyone is wrong and vaguely gesture toward info that no one else can see, regardless of the contents of that info.

8 Likes

It’s almost impossible for me to debate you in this forum. I cannot think of any appropriate answer to your question that would not be promptly removed by this forum’s moderators. Even my anodyne comment above was briefly removed.

I’ve spent several hours rewriting this comment, trying to figure out what I can say without making things even worse. Here is my best attempt: Nirbheek’s article from The Atlantic was truly spot on, documenting almost precisely the situation that has occurred here. He didn’t even have to do anything to make his argument other than post the hyperlink and then let you fill in the rest for him. You and Victoria (and others) have manufactured this crisis yourselves and caused so much damage.

It now seems you are accusing him of anti-LGBTQ sentiment. This is a very serious claim. There had better be very strong evidence for this. I certainly will not take your word for it.